Viviscal Vs Rogaine: Which Is Better For Hair Growth In 2024?

Medically reviewed by Dr. Amy Revene M.B.B.S.
Written by Our Editorial Team
Last updated

Are you on the hunt for the best solution to tackle hair loss? It's a common journey many of us find ourselves on, and navigating the myriad of treatments out there can feel overwhelming.

Among the top contenders in the battle for fuller, thicker hair are Viviscal and Rogaine. Both have carved out significant reputations in the hair growth industry, but which one actually takes the crown for effectiveness?

In this article, we'll dive deep into Viviscal vs Rogaine, breaking down how each product works, their benefits, side effects, and ultimately, which might be the better choice for your hair growth journey.

What is Viviscal?

viviscal vs rogaine

Viviscal is a brand known primarily for its hair growth supplements designed for both men and women. They also offer a range of topical hair care products, including shampoos, conditioners, scalp scrubs, and serums.

Viviscal's supplements are recognized for their unique blend of vitamins, minerals, and a proprietary marine complex, designed to treat hair loss and stimulate hair growth by nourishing thinning hair.

Alongside the supplements, their topical products aim to provide a holistic approach to hair health, addressing both internal nourishment and external care. The brand has undergone clinical trials and studies to validate its efficacy, making it a popular choice for those seeking solutions to hair thinning or loss.

Their products

  • Hair growth supplements: Tailored formulas for both men and women to nourish thinning hair and promote existing hair growth.
  • Shampoo: Designed to cleanse and strengthen the hair, aiding in the prevention of breakage.
  • Conditioner: Complements the shampoo, moisturizing and thickening the hair.
  • Exfoliating scalp scrub: Helps to remove dead skin cells, promoting a healthier scalp environment.
  • Hair serum: Targets hair thinning and promotes the appearance of thicker hair.

How does Viviscal work?

promote hair growth and reduce scalp irritation

Viviscal functions to stimulate hair growth by extending the anagen phase, which is crucial for producing healthier and stronger hair. Clinical studies have demonstrated that users saw a significant reduction in hair loss and an improvement in hair density, attributing to the efficacy of these hair loss treatments within 90 days of use.

The hair growth cycle consists of different phases, with the anagen phase being the active growth period. By extending this phase, Viviscal aims not only to allow hair to grow longer but also to increase the number of hairs in the growth phase, addressing issues of male pattern baldness and thinning hair.

What are the key ingredients in Viviscal?

The key ingredients in Viviscal include the AminoMar Complex (a blend of marine collagen proteins and fatty acids), Horsetail Extract, Niacin (Vitamin B3), Ana-Tel Formula with pea sprouts and marine collagen, and other vital proteins such as keratin, biotin, collagen, and zinc.

  • AminoMar complex: Derived from marine sources, this complex is inspired by the diets of the Inuits. It combines marine collagen proteins and fatty acids to boost hair volume and stimulate growth.
  • Horsetail extract: This natural extract plays a role in balancing hormones by ensuring calcium and magnesium levels in the body are stable. This can indirectly support hair health.
  • Niacin (Vitamin B3): An essential vitamin that increases blood flow, ensuring that more nutrients reach the hair follicles. This increased nourishment can enhance hair growth.
  • Ana-Tel formula: A specialized blend that includes scalp-nourishing ingredients like pea sprouts, marine collagen, zinc, and seaweed extract. Together, they work to create a healthier scalp environment conducive to hair growth.
  • Other key proteins: Proteins like keratin, biotin, collagen, and zinc are fundamental in hair health. They contribute to building and strengthening hair fibers, making hair more resilient and less prone to breakage.

Are there any side effects of Viviscal?

Yes, Viviscal does have some side effects. Here are the details: 

  • Fish allergy: Since Viviscal contains shark-derived components, anyone with a fish allergy should avoid taking the supplement to prevent allergic reactions.
  • Pregnancy & breastfeeding: It's advised that pregnant or breastfeeding women avoid taking Viviscal, as the safety of the product during these periods has not been definitively established.
  • Millet seed allergy: For individuals allergic to Millet Seed, Viviscal could trigger allergic reactions. It's essential to review the product's ingredients thoroughly and consult with a healthcare professional if unsure.

Pros and cons of Viviscal

Balancing the allure of natural, drug-free ingredients with the patience required for visible results, Viviscal presents a unique proposition in hair care.

Pros:

  • Offers a diverse range of products targeting scalp nourishment and hair restoration.
  • Utilizes a range of natural, drug-free ingredients, making it a holistic approach to hair care.
  • Limited reported side effects, suggesting it's generally well-tolerated by users.

Cons:

  • Results may vary, with some users needing up to 6 months before noticing significant improvements.

What is Rogaine?

viviscal vs rogaine

Rogaine is an FDA-approved over-the-counter hair loss treatment containing topical minoxidil. Applied directly to the scalp, it requires three to six months of daily use for results, and continuous use is needed to maintain its benefits.

Initially developed as a treatment for high blood pressure, oral minoxidil was serendipitously found to also stimulate hair growth as a beneficial side effect. Capitalizing on this finding, Rogaine was formulated as a topical solution to address hair thinning and loss.

How does Rogaine work?

hair supplements for lose hair and noticeable hair growth

Rogaine uses minoxidil to increase blood flow and expand blood vessels in the scalp, aiming to stop hair loss and stimulate the regrowth of hair. This process not only extends the active growth phase (anagen) but also, according to Utkan Kızıltaç, MD, leads to an initial shedding phase.

Dr. Kızıltaç explains, "Drugs with minoxidil active ingredient cause all the hair in the telogen phase to fall out and grow in the anagen phase for the first 4-8 weeks. This is the reason for your hair loss." This phase is crucial for the long-term effectiveness of Rogaine, as it clears the way for new, healthy hair growth.

While Rogaine is adept at halting or slowing hair loss, its ability to regrow already lost hair is less certain, underscoring the importance of early treatment.

What are the key ingredients in Rogaine?

The primary active ingredient in Rogaine is minoxidil. Rogaine products are available in different concentrations of minoxidil, with 2% solutions typically recommended for women and 5% solutions often suggested for men. 

There are also foam and liquid formulations, each containing additional inactive ingredients to stabilize the product and enhance its application. 

However, it's the minoxidil component that is the primary agent combating hair thinning and promoting hair growth.

Are there any side effects of Rogaine?

While many people use Rogaine without experiencing significant side effects, it's essential to be aware of potential reactions. Some of the side effects associated with Rogaine include:

  • Facial swelling: This can occur as an allergic reaction to the product.
  • Scalp acne: Some users may develop pimples or irritation on the scalp.
  • Chest pains: This is a more severe side effect, and if experienced, one should seek medical attention immediately.
  • Weight gain: A less common side effect, but it has been reported by some users.

Pros and cons of Rogaine

Rogaine, a renowned name in the hair growth industry, brings hope to many but also presents certain challenges to users. Let's delve into its advantages and potential drawbacks.

Pros:

  • Rogaine stands out as one of the few treatments specifically harnessing minoxidil to combat hair loss and promote regrowth.
  • Offers relatively quick results, with some users noticing changes within a few months.

Cons:

  • Predominantly relies on chemical-heavy ingredients, lacking additional nourishing components.
  • Comes with the risk of potentially severe side effects, making it essential for users to monitor their reactions.
  • Continuous application is required to maintain results, making it a long-term commitment.

Viviscal vs Rogaine: What are the differences?

Viviscal promotes hair growth by nourishing follicles from within, reducing shedding and improving hair health, whereas Rogaine stimulates growth by enhancing scalp blood flow to rejuvenate follicles, without addressing the underlying causes of hair loss.

Here are some of the other differences:

Product range

Viviscal provides a broad spectrum of hair care treatments, from topical solutions to dietary supplements. In contrast, Rogaine primarily offers two main products: a topical solution and a foam, with gender-specific formulations for each.

Approach

While Viviscal champions a holistic, natural, and drug-free methodology, Rogaine is more straightforward with its chemical-heavy composition, which, despite potential side effects, has been proven effective in stimulating hair growth.

Brand recognition

Both brands have significant market presence, but Rogaine might edge out slightly in terms of being a household name in the hair loss sector.

Purpose

Rogaine's mission is unambiguous: to thwart hair loss and champion regrowth. Viviscal, on the other hand, focuses more holistically on fostering thicker, healthier hair.

Pricing

A quick glance at the wallet impact: Viviscal's topical treatments (like shampoo, conditioner, and serum) hover around $13, and their supplements sit at $36 for a month's supply. Meanwhile, Rogaine for Women is priced at roughly $20 for a two-month supply.

An effective alternative to Viviscal and Rogaine

viviscal vs rogaine

Bio-Pilixin Serum presents a promising alternative to Viviscal and Rogaine. Developed with stem cell technology, it boasts plant growth factors aimed at nourishing hair follicles and promoting growth. 

Clinically proven results in just 45 days, a 93% satisfaction rate from clinical study participants, and a drug-free composition make it an enticing choice. 

Why Bio-Pilixin Serum is a good alternative

  • Plant growth factors: Leveraging the power of stem cell technology, the serum is designed to nurture hair follicles and spur hair growth.
  • Rapid results: While some products require months to show results, Bio-Pilixin® boasts visible outcomes in as few as 45 days.
  • Clinical backing: A 93% satisfaction rate from a clinical study indicates that the majority of users found the product effective.
  • Safety first: The serum is drug-free, making it suitable for daily use without the concerns of potential long-term drug-related side effects.
  • 150-Day money-back guarantee: This demonstrates the brand's confidence in its product and provides customers with peace of mind.
  • Quality ingredients: Each ingredient, whether naturally-derived or molecularly mimicked, undergoes rigorous scientific review and third-party lab testing. The 100% vegan formula stands as a testament to its commitment to natural solutions.

Highlighted ingredients:

  • Capilia Longa: Research has shown up to an 89% reduction in hair loss and up to a 52% improvement in hair density.
  • Niacinamide: This stimulates keratin production, a vital protein that constitutes about 90% of the hair shaft.
  • Vanillyl Butyl Ether: This agent produces a warming sensation on the scalp, potentially boosting blood flow and nutrient delivery.

Bio-Pilixin® Activation Serum | For Men
Bio-Pilixin® Activation Serum | For Men
Drug-free & clinically tested

Viviscal vs Rogaine: Which one is better for you?

If you lean towards a natural, holistic approach to support overall hair health, Viviscal might be the better choice. For those specifically targeting hair loss and seeking proven regrowth solutions, Rogaine could be more suitable. It's essential to consult with a dermatologist or hair care expert to determine the best fit for your hair concerns.

Conclusion

In the search for effective hair growth solutions, Viviscal and Rogaine emerge as leading options, each with distinct approaches—Viviscal’s holistic method enhances overall hair health with natural ingredients, while Rogaine uses a scientific formula to combat hair loss and foster regrowth.

Alternatively, Bio-Pilixin Serum combines plant growth factors with proven ingredients for rapid results and offers a 150-day money-back guarantee, representing a blend of nature and science.

Choosing the right product—Viviscal, Rogaine, or Bio-Pilixin—depends on personal health goals and preferences.

Consistency and patience are crucial, along with professional advice for informed decisions.

FAQs

Can I take Viviscal with Rogaine?

Yes, it's possible to use Viviscal and Rogaine simultaneously. Combining these treatments can address hair loss from both an internal nutritional and external treatment approach, potentially enhancing overall results.

Does Viviscal work to regrow hair?

Based on clinical studies and customer feedback, Viviscal has been effective for many women, aiding in hair regrowth to some extent. However, it's not guaranteed to regrow thinning hair for everyone, and results may vary, with some users experiencing benefits such as enhanced shine.

Does Viviscal stop balding?

While Viviscal is not a cure for hereditary hair loss, it can contribute positively by strengthening existing hair, increasing volume, and minimizing hair loss from non-genetic factors. This can improve the overall health and appearance of your hair.

Who cannot use Rogaine?

Individuals with scalp conditions (like eczema or infections), heart issues (including chest pain or heart failure), and those with kidney or liver disease should consult a healthcare provider before using Rogaine to avoid potential adverse effects.

Is Viviscal a DHT blocker?

Yes, Viviscal contains flaxseed, which is believed to block DHT, a hormone linked to male pattern baldness. Additionally, it has 36.4% more zinc than its Extra Strength version, enhancing its potential to mitigate hair loss.

What happens if I stop Viviscal?

Discontinuing Viviscal may not lead to immediate noticeable changes for everyone. However, over time, some individuals might observe their hair gradually thinning again, suggesting the benefits of Viviscal may diminish after cessation.

References:

  1. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12196747/
  2. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6691938/
  3. https://www.jaad.org/article/S0190-9622(03)03692-2/fulltext

Read more: 

Dr Amy Revene M.B.B.S. graduated from the University of Sharjah in the United Arab Emirates. She is currently working as a General Physician at New Hope Medical Center. Amy has a passion for research and offers her expertise and opinions to help people in their quest to lead healthy, happy lives.